Most New York employers have a significant blind spot in their hiring process – and they don't even know it. If you're making hiring decisions based on standard background checks in the Empire State, you're likely working with incomplete information, despite premium prices.
Here's what makes New York uniquely challenging: Unlike other states, where county courts handle both felonies and misdemeanors, New York's county courts exclusively hear felony cases. This creates a fundamental gap in the traditional background screening approach that most employers rely on.
When you run a county criminal search in New York and discover a misdemeanor, what you've actually found is the exception – a case that initially began as a felony before being reduced during proceedings. The vast majority of misdemeanors, which are processed through local, town, and city courts, simply won't appear in these searches.
The New York State Office of Court Administration (NYS OCA) offers a valuable statewide search option that captures more comprehensive information, but it comes with its own set of limitations. At $95 per name plus processing fees, it represents a significant investment. The system requires exact name matches, operates under specific reporting policies, and may extend your hiring timeline with its processing periods.
For organizations that need to balance thorough screening with hiring velocity and budget constraints, these challenges demand a more nuanced approach. That's why understanding the full landscape of NY background check options is essential for making informed decisions.
The Misdemeanor Blindspot: Why County Searches Fail in New York
If you're like most employers, county criminal searches are your background check bread and butter. In 49 states, that's a solid approach. But New York? It's a completely different animal.
Unlike virtually every other state in the country, New York's county courts handle felony cases exclusively. This seemingly minor administrative detail creates a massive blind spot in your background screening process because misdemeanors, which often include serious offenses, are adjudicated at the local, town, and city court levels instead.
Let's be crystal clear about what this means. When you run a standard county criminal search in New York, you're systematically missing misdemeanors in your applicant's record.
The only misdemeanors that show up in county searches are those that began as felony charges but were later reduced during plea bargaining or court proceedings. These represent just a fraction of all misdemeanor convictions in the state. Here's a sampling of New York misdemeanors that have been missed by a county search:
-
Forcible Touching (a sex offense)
-
Operating a Motor Vehicle Under the Influence
-
Criminal Possession of a Weapon
-
Endangering the Welfare of a Child
-
Aggravated Harassment
-
Assault
-
Criminal Possession of Controlled Substances
-
Petit Larceny
Some of these offenses would be felonies in other states but are classified as misdemeanors in New York. Each one represents critical information for making informed hiring decisions, especially for roles involving vulnerable populations, financial responsibilities, or safety concerns.
Multi-County Complexity
The problem compounds when candidates have lived in multiple New York counties. With 62 counties and over 1,300 town and village courts, tracking down complete records becomes a logistical nightmare. Each jurisdiction maintains its own records, with varying access methods, fees, and processing times.
Some counties, like those covering the five boroughs of New York City, have their own specialized court systems, adding another layer of complexity. And 13 New York counties don't even offer direct county searches—they require going through the expensive NYS Office of Court Administration process.
The Verification Challenge
Even when misdemeanor cases are identified through alternative methods, verifying details often requires contacting individual courts, many of which demand paper forms, money orders, and fees ranging from $5 to $65 per search. Some courts won't release information by phone or email at all, requiring in-person or mailed requests that can take weeks to process.
For employers with high-volume hiring needs, this creates an impossible choice: accept incomplete information, blow your budget on comprehensive searches, or delay hiring decisions until complete information can be gathered.
Either way, employers end up paying too much for too little information, making hiring decisions without the complete picture, and potentially exposing themselves to negligent hiring liability. This fundamental gap in New York background checks isn't just a compliance issue—it's a business risk that demands a better solution.
The NYS Office of Court Administration (OCA) Search — The Expensive Half-Solution
The New York State Office of Court Administration (OCA) search represents an important resource in the New York background screening landscape. It provides access to criminal records across the state's jurisdictions through a centralized source, offering certain advantages over county-level searches alone. However, like any screening tool, it comes with specific considerations that employers should understand.
At $95 per name plus processing fees, the NYS OCA search represents a significant investment in your screening process. This price point makes it one of the more costly criminal record searches nationwide—approximately three times the price of comparable searches in many other states. For organizations with high-volume hiring needs, this can create meaningful budget implications.
The question becomes not whether the search has value, but whether it's the most cost-effective option for every position and hiring scenario.
The Misdemeanor Redemption Policy: Your Blind Spot by Design
Since April 2014, the NYS OCA has implemented what they euphemistically call their "Misdemeanor Redemption Policy." This means they will no longer report criminal history for individuals whose only conviction was a single misdemeanor more than ten years prior to your request. Sounds reasonable until you realize how this plays out in practice.
The redemption policy becomes particularly problematic when combined with the OCA's exact-match limitations. In a recent case study, our team found a candidate with multiple criminal convictions, but the NYS OCA failed to report one conviction because of a one-letter difference in the spelling of the candidate's first name. This minor variation created what was essentially a separate record in their system - one misdemeanor that then disappeared under the Redemption Policy despite the candidate having multiple other convictions.
This isn't just about giving people a second chance after a decade of good behavior - it's about database architecture creating artificial blind spots in your screening process.
No Fuzzy Logic: When Exact Matching Exactly Fails
The NYS OCA system operates on precise name and date of birth matching, which ensures accuracy but can create information gaps in certain scenarios:
-
If your candidate has a suffix recorded on one conviction (like "Jr." or "Sr.") but not on another, you might not find both convictions, depending on how the subject information was submitted.
-
If there was a clerical error in entering their name or DOB (which happens with surprising frequency), those records vanish.
-
If your candidate has used multiple spellings of their name (think "Bob" vs. "Robert"), you'll miss relevant records.
In one particularly troubling case study, the NYS OCA reported absolutely no results for a candidate who was, in fact, a registered sex offender. Why? A data entry error where the day in their DOB was entered as "4" instead of "14". When we accessed the court directly with the correct information, we found the conviction immediately.
Speed: The Final Insult
As if incomplete data at premium prices wasn't enough, the NYS OCA typically processes requests efficiently, but timelines can vary:
-
Standard processing typically takes 1-2 business days.
-
During high-volume periods, expect 3-5 business days.
-
Add in holidays (the NYS OCA observes 12 holidays annually, compared to 8 for most private services), and your hiring timeline stretches even further.
The NYS OCA search serves as a valuable resource in many situations, particularly for the most sensitive positions. However, complementing it with alternative screening methods can provide a more comprehensive and cost-effective solution for your overall hiring program. By understanding the strengths and limitations of each option, you can develop a nuanced screening strategy that allocates your budget effectively while maintaining thorough coverage across different hiring scenarios.
The NY Checked™ Solution
After reading about the minefield of New York criminal background checks, you're probably wondering if there's a solution that doesn't force you to choose between incomplete information, budget-busting costs, or glacial turnaround times.
There is—and it's called NY Checked™.
While most background check providers were content to pass along the limitations of the New York system to their clients (along with the hefty price tag), we took a different approach. In 1999, our president, Michelle Pyan, began working with the New York State Law Enforcement to develop a more comprehensive, cost-effective solution. By 2011, this collaboration resulted in NY Checked™—a proprietary database that revolutionizes how New York criminal information is accessed and verified.
Unlike database-only searches, NY Checked™ combines law enforcement data with thorough investigative follow-up. The result? A criminal search that outperforms both county-level searches and the expensive NYS OCA option.
The NY Checked™ Difference
Let's compare apples to apples—what exactly makes NY Checked™ superior to your current options?
Unlike the NYS OCA search, which only returns exact name matches and requires a full date of birth, NY Checked™ positively identifies subjects using multiple identifiers—name, date of birth, social security number, and address. This ensures you're getting the right records for the right person, without false positives or false negatives.
At $32.50 per name—roughly one-third the cost of the NYS OCA search—NY Checked™ delivers more comprehensive information at a fraction of the price. For organizations processing hundreds or thousands of background checks annually, the savings are substantial.
Beyond the direct cost savings, NY Checked™ dramatically improves hiring velocity with results typically available within 2 - 4 hours, not days or weeks. By accessing booking records across local, town, and city criminal data sources, NY Checked™ captures the misdemeanor information that county searches systematically miss while overcoming the redemption policy limitations and exact-match restrictions of the NYS OCA search.
Protecting Your Organization in the Empire State
New York's criminal record system is uniquely challenging, and employers who rely on conventional background check approaches are making decisions based on incomplete information, often at premium prices.
In today's environment, where talent acquisition is challenging, budgets are tight, and liability risks are significant, New York employers can't afford to continue with suboptimal background check approaches. The stakes are simply too high.
That's where we come in. For over two decades, our team has helped thousands of New York employers implement background check programs that balance thoroughness, speed, compliance, and cost-effectiveness. Our NY Checked™ solution isn't just a database—it's backed by licensed private investigators who understand the nuances of New York's criminal court system.
Don't wait for a bad hire or a compliance issue to reevaluate your approach to New York background checks. Call (518) 271-7546 to schedule a consultation with our team to assess how NY Checked™ can provide more complete information at a lower cost.
When it comes to protecting your organization, your employees, and the people you serve, incomplete information isn't just expensive—it's reckless.
